You want your investments to reflect your faith. Then you look at the fees and wonder how much that conviction is going to cost.
That's a reasonable concern. Money spent on fund expenses is money that can't stay invested, support your family, or be given away. A Christian label doesn't make that tradeoff disappear.
But choosing investments involves more than finding the lowest expense ratio. If you care about the businesses you own, you also need to understand how a fund selects those businesses and whether its approach reflects your convictions.
That leaves a practical question: when a faith-based fund costs more, what are you actually getting for the difference?
How much more do faith-based funds charge?
Morningstar's 2026 report, Faith-Based Investing: Global Landscape, found a substantial fee gap among passive funds. In its global large-cap equity comparison, faith-based passive funds generally charged roughly twice the asset-weighted average fees of their nonreligious counterparts, using data as of April 30, 2026.
There are some important boundaries around that finding. The report covers multiple religious traditions, including Christian, Catholic, and Islamic funds. It isn't saying that every Christian fund costs twice as much as an otherwise identical conventional fund. Its active-fund results also varied by religious category, so the passive-fund finding shouldn't become a blanket claim about all faith-based investing.
Still, the finding gives investors a good reason to look closely at expenses.
Morningstar points to smaller fund sizes and limited economies of scale as likely explanations for the passive-fund premium. A fund with a smaller pool of assets has fewer dollars over which to spread its operating costs. Less competition may also reduce pressure to lower fees.
Those explanations matter because a higher fee doesn't necessarily mean you're receiving more extensive screening or more shareholder engagement. Some of the premium may simply reflect the economics of a smaller fund.
You can understand why a fund costs more and still decide that another approach offers better value.
Start with what you want your investments to own
Before comparing funds, it helps to put your own convictions into words.
For a Christian investor, that starts with a question about ownership. When you buy stock, directly or through a fund, you hold an ownership interest in a business. You may have little influence over its decisions, but you still have a reason to consider what that business does.
Scripture treats our resources as something entrusted to us. Psalm 24:1 begins, "The earth is the LORD's and the fullness thereof" (ESV). That changes how we approach investing: we are making decisions about resources that ultimately belong to God.
It doesn't hand us an approved fund list. We still have to think carefully about how to apply that responsibility.
One investor may be most concerned about a company's primary source of revenue. Another may also want to consider its business practices, treatment of employees, or involvement in activities that conflict with the investor's beliefs. Christians can share a commitment to faithful stewardship and reach different conclusions about where to draw those lines.
The more clearly you can describe your concerns, the easier it becomes to evaluate a fund. "I want Christian investments" gives you a label to shop for. "I want to avoid businesses that earn revenue from these activities" gives you something you can check.
If you're still working through that distinction, Christian ETFs: A Practical Guide provides more background on how these funds work.
What should the higher fee buy?
A useful place to start is the fund's screening policy. Which business activities trigger an exclusion? Does any involvement disqualify a company, or does the policy allow revenue up to a stated threshold? How often are holdings reviewed?
Those details can produce very different portfolios. A policy that excludes a company whose main business is gambling may still allow a company with a small gambling-related revenue stream. Whether that distinction is acceptable depends on your convictions, but you need to know it exists before deciding the fund fits.
Morningstar found that funds sharing a denominational label can differ materially in their exclusions. A familiar name on the brochure is therefore only a starting point. Read the prospectus, screening methodology, and holdings together. If a holding surprises you, ask how it passed the screen.
Some investors also care about how a manager uses its position as a shareholder. A fund may vote on corporate proposals or engage with company leadership. If those activities are part of its appeal, look for a published voting policy and examples of what the manager has actually done. Engagement can be a legitimate part of an investment approach, but a promise to "influence companies" tells you very little by itself.
Then consider how well the fund performs its basic investment job. Does it provide the exposure you need? Is it reasonably diversified? Can you understand its construction and ongoing expenses?
A thoughtful screen doesn't remove the need for sound portfolio management. You're still buying an investment, and it needs to make sense within your financial plan.
The screen can change more than the fee
The expense ratio is the easiest cost to identify. It isn't the only tradeoff.
Excluding companies can change a portfolio's exposure to industries, company sizes, or investment styles. A fund may behave differently from a broad-market index because it owns a meaningfully different collection of businesses.
For example, Morningstar's report found that Christian funds were notably underweight healthcare. That doesn't establish what any particular fund will hold, but it illustrates why investors need to look beyond the exclusion list. A screen aimed at certain business activities can also change the portfolio's sector exposure.
Those differences may help performance in one period and hurt it in another. Neither outcome, by itself, proves that the screening policy is wise or foolish. It does mean you should understand the differences before you encounter them in your account.
A faith-based fund shouldn't come with an expectation that conviction guarantees better returns. It also shouldn't require you to stop asking questions about performance, diversification, or risk.
If a manager explains every disappointing result by pointing to the fund's mission, keep asking. There should still be a coherent explanation of how the portfolio was built and what drove its results. I explore that issue further in Does Biblically Responsible Investing Cost You Money?.
Turn the fee difference into dollars
"Twice the fee" can sound more informative than it is. The dollar cost depends on the starting fee and the amount invested.
Consider a hypothetical comparison between two funds charging 0.25% and 0.50% annually. On a constant $100,000 balance, those expense ratios represent approximately $250 and $500 a year, respectively. The difference is about $250.
That's a simplified illustration, not a quote for any particular fund. Actual expenses in dollars vary with account value, and the expense ratio doesn't necessarily capture every cost of an investment approach, such as trading costs, advisory fees, or taxes.
The point is to make the decision concrete. Would you choose to pay roughly $250 more each year for the screening approach you're considering? What would you expect to receive for that amount? Would your answer change if the screen addressed only some of your concerns?
The premium also recurs. Over time, paying higher expenses leaves less money invested, all else equal. The eventual effect depends on balances, returns, and the length of time involved, but it deserves more consideration than a glance at a decimal.
A fee can be affordable and still be poor value. It can also be higher than an alternative and be an expense you deliberately choose. Understanding the dollars helps you make that choice without minimizing the cost or exaggerating it.
Compare realistic alternatives
Once you understand the screen and its cost, compare it with other ways of meeting the same goal.
Start with other faith-based funds serving a similar portfolio role. Compare their actual policies, diversification, expenses, and shareholder practices. A cheaper fund that doesn't address your concerns may not solve your problem. A more expensive one needs a reason for the difference beyond its branding.
Some investors also consider separately managed or custom-screened portfolios. Those approaches may allow more control over exclusions, but they can introduce advisory or platform fees, account minimums, tax considerations, and additional complexity. More customization isn't automatically better value.
The right comparison is between approaches you could realistically use, with the full costs visible. If an advisor recommends one, ask how the advisor is paid and whether a less expensive option could meet the same need.
You also don't have to resolve every question about every holding before taking a thoughtful next step. Screening policies rely on definitions and information that deserve scrutiny. What matters is having a process you can understand, apply, and revisit as you learn more.
A Christian label still needs to earn your trust
A faith-based fund may be a useful way to put your convictions into practice. Its fee deserves the same scrutiny you would give any other recurring expense.
Before paying more, be able to explain what the fund excludes, how that affects the portfolio, and what the difference costs in dollars. Then consider whether another approach could meet your needs at a lower cost or with fewer compromises.
You may decide the premium is worthwhile because the policy addresses concerns that matter to you. You may discover that the screen doesn't match your convictions closely enough to justify the expense. Either conclusion can follow from taking stewardship seriously.
The goal is to make an informed ownership decision, with a clear understanding of what you're paying for and what you're giving up.
Want some help thinking this through?
I did too. That's part of why I started Openhanded Wealth: to walk with folks like you through decisions that feel complicated, but don't have to stay that way.
If you've got questions, reach out. I'm a real person, and I won't pressure you into buying products you don't need. You don't have to navigate this alone.
Source
Morningstar, Faith-Based Investing: Global Landscape, 2026. Fee discussion and Exhibit 11 use global large-cap equity funds and data as of April 30, 2026. The report covers multiple religious traditions; its averages are not quotes for individual funds.
This content is provided for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. Nothing contained herein constitutes a recommendation to buy or sell any security or to adopt any specific investment strategy. Strategies discussed may not be appropriate for all individuals and depend on each person’s unique financial circumstances. Investment advisory services are offered only pursuant to a written advisory agreement.
My goal is to use whatever gifts I have received to serve others, as a faithful steward of God’s grace in its various forms. (1 Peter 4:10)
Better is a handful, with quietness, than two handfuls with labor and striving after wind. -Ecclesiastes 4:6
Take the next step towards openhandedness and financial peace by booking a meeting with a Christian Financial Planner.




